|
Post by mbogo on Sept 17, 2011 17:16:46 GMT -5
www.prbullet.com/I wanted a flatter shooting bullet for my mule deer hunt in December so I bought some of the 195 grn .357s and 260 grn .40s to test in my Savage. In limited shooting thus far, the .357s are shooting similar size groups to Barnes 260 grn MZs and slightly better than the Hornady XTPs I had been using. My concern is how they perform on deer at the velocities my Savage propels them, especially at mid-ranges. Anyone else usedthese bullets and killed a deer with them?
|
|
|
Post by HuntMeister on Sept 17, 2011 19:42:48 GMT -5
Are you talking smokeless porpellents? What kind of groups are you getting with them? Do you know your velocity with them?
I do not have any firsthand experience with them but am interested in them myself.
|
|
|
Post by mbogo on Sept 17, 2011 20:55:34 GMT -5
Yes, smokeless powder. I've been shooting 44.5 grains of 5744 thus far with the .357s. I haven't shot the .40s yet. Groups have averaged about 1.5", which is about as good as I can do with my setup. I don't have a chrony so no idea on the velocity for smokeless but I think I read on the site that people were getting around 2200 fps with 777 or blackpowder out of Encores. I would imagine smokeless loads can easily approach the low end of .358 wssm level velocities.
BTW, I am using the MMP sub-bases on every load. Based on the fit of just the sabot, I doubt they will shoot as well without them.
|
|
|
Post by HuntMeister on Sept 17, 2011 21:10:31 GMT -5
I am just getting into the smokeless scene. I've been playing around with FTX's and TEZ's in the 250gn weight in my Encore / SMI rifle. I don't know how hard you could push the dead centers but strictly a guess that they being lead would not handle the higher pressures. I would imagine the small for bore diameter of them would present problems as well. I did get around 2500FPS last weekend with the above mentioned bullets. Have you ever ventured over to Doug's message board? LOTS of good folks and great info to be found there on the smokeless option. Keep us posted on your progress.
|
|
|
Post by mbogo on Sept 18, 2011 9:49:13 GMT -5
Yes, I've been to Doug's board a few times especially when I first started with smokeless. My understanding of the mechanics of firing lead bullets is that the pressure has to be kept relatively low to keep the gas from cutting past the base of the bullet. The sabot and to a greater extent, in this case, the sub-base alleviates that concern. Incidently, I have recovered nearly every sub-base I have fired, they were all in a neat little pile about 40 yards from the muzzle.
If the .40s shoot well, I will likely make them my choice for hunting because I feel a little more comfortable about the extra weight and larger diameter performing well on deer. I'll let you know how they perform when I take something with them.
|
|
|
Post by esshup on Sept 18, 2011 11:57:16 GMT -5
The smokeless Savage can approach if not exceed the upper end of the .358 WSSM loads.........
Get yourself some 300 grain .458 dia barnes origional bullets. Use the sabot that your gun likes (Orange MMP or Crush Rib Harvestor). Go to Dougs and look at some of the different powders that are used for that bullet. There is a sticky there with different powders and weights. You should be getting way less than 1" groups with the gun. No sub-base is needed with the correct powder. The all lead bullets just won't perform at the velocities that the Savage is capable of.
You need to up the bullet diameter to get better groups. That's why the .45 cal barrels are so popular, they shoot the smaller dia bullets better than the .50 cal barrels.
My ML-I (first generation Savage) will shoot the .452 dia 250g Hornady SST or T/C Shockwave bullets in less than 1/2" groups (c-c) with 43.5g of IMR-4759 (Old metal can). Velocity is slightly over 2300 fps. I haven't played around with the newer Stainless ML-II to get the groups really dialed in, but it shoots good enough to take Indiana whitetails out to 260 Yds using that same load. I use the MMP short black sabot with that bullet.
I have a Pac-Nor .45 cal barrel on order for the Stainless ML-II. 200g Barnes bullets, and the Harvestor smooth blue sabots will be the projectile. I'm guessing that they'll do very well in the 2800 fps range.
|
|
|
Post by hornharvester on Sept 18, 2011 13:15:20 GMT -5
www.prbullet.com/I wanted a flatter shooting bullet for my mule deer hunt in December so I bought some of the 195 grn .357s and 260 grn .40s to test in my Savage. In limited shooting thus far, the .357s are shooting similar size groups to Barnes 260 grn MZs and slightly better than the Hornady XTPs I had been using. My concern is how they perform on deer at the velocities my Savage propels them, especially at mid-ranges. Anyone else usedthese bullets and killed a deer with them? With smokeless powder being careful of mis-fires with them especially if the gun has been loaded for a while.
|
|
|
Post by hornharvester on Sept 18, 2011 13:26:39 GMT -5
|
|
|
Post by mbogo on Sept 18, 2011 16:26:02 GMT -5
The smokeless Savage can approach if not exceed the upper end of the .358 WSSM loads......... Get yourself some 300 grain .458 dia barnes origional bullets. Use the sabot that your gun likes (Orange MMP or Crush Rib Harvestor). Go to Dougs and look at some of the different powders that are used for that bullet. There is a sticky there with different powders and weights. You should be getting way less than 1" groups with the gun. No sub-base is needed with the correct powder. The all lead bullets just won't perform at the velocities that the Savage is capable of. You need to up the bullet diameter to get better groups. That's why the .45 cal barrels are so popular, they shoot the smaller dia bullets better than the .50 cal barrels. My ML-I (first generation Savage) will shoot the .452 dia 250g Hornady SST or T/C Shockwave bullets in less than 1/2" groups (c-c) with 43.5g of IMR-4759 (Old metal can). Velocity is slightly over 2300 fps. I haven't played around with the newer Stainless ML-II to get the groups really dialed in, but it shoots good enough to take Indiana whitetails out to 260 Yds using that same load. I use the MMP short black sabot with that bullet. I have a Pac-Nor .45 cal barrel on order for the Stainless ML-II. 200g Barnes bullets, and the Harvestor smooth blue sabots will be the projectile. I'm guessing that they'll do very well in the 2800 fps range. Let me clarify, accuracy is not a problem nor a concern for me with these bullets. Again, the initial load shot as well as Barnes .45 260 grain bullets and better than Hornady .45 XTPs. I have no doubt that the Savage is capable of shooting 1" or better groups but not from the portable bench setup I shoot from.
|
|
|
Post by mbogo on Sept 18, 2011 16:27:06 GMT -5
www.prbullet.com/I wanted a flatter shooting bullet for my mule deer hunt in December so I bought some of the 195 grn .357s and 260 grn .40s to test in my Savage. In limited shooting thus far, the .357s are shooting similar size groups to Barnes 260 grn MZs and slightly better than the Hornady XTPs I had been using. My concern is how they perform on deer at the velocities my Savage propels them, especially at mid-ranges. Anyone else usedthese bullets and killed a deer with them? With smokeless powder being careful of mis-fires with them especially if the gun has been loaded for a while. Why is that? Do you have direct experience with these bullets?
|
|
|
Post by esshup on Sept 18, 2011 23:27:55 GMT -5
Read about it in the link, it's explained there.
|
|
|
Post by hornharvester on Sept 18, 2011 23:37:50 GMT -5
No, but in the past members at Dougs did when they left the gun loaded for a few days. 5744 is probably the best choice for powder if you are going to use the PR. For distance I would use a heavy bullet like the Barnes Originals 300 grain, 295 Barnes Spitfire or 300 XTP.
Sub bases are the only reason you probably arent having misfires now. The BO, Harvester Crushed Rib Black sabot with 60grains of Vv120 is a very good load for distance of 300 yards. 43 - 46 grains of 5744 and a 300 XTP is another good shooter out to 200 yards. Not sure how far you want the gun to shoot. Over the years Ive read guys having too many misfires to bank my money on a great hunt using a load that has history of misfires and you know it wont happen until that buck of a lifetime steps into your sights. h.h.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Sept 19, 2011 12:49:31 GMT -5
I use them, they kill wonderfully effiecent. I have had a few misfire issues with the Savage barrel, and no longer load them in it, but the Smokeless Muzzleloading barrel likes them very well.
|
|
|
Post by HuntMeister on Sept 19, 2011 13:17:29 GMT -5
I use them, they kill wonderfully effiecent. I have had a few misfire issues with the Savage barrel, and no longer load them in it, but the Smokeless Muzzleloading barrel likes them very well. Can you share your load details? I too have the SMI on my Encore and would be interested in trying them in mine.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Sept 19, 2011 14:51:01 GMT -5
I generally use 5744, as hot as my shoulder can stand. These bullets are soft lead, but I've never recovered one yet, always punching through both sides. Hammers big body bucks like dropping a ton of bricks on them. But I've never killed one at over 150 yards yet, so don't know if they are the best choice for long range shooting or not.
|
|
|
Post by mbogo on Sept 19, 2011 19:20:25 GMT -5
Ah, I guess I didn't read far enough into the link because all I saw was info about 300 grain barnes loads. I will have to do some testing by loading one up and leaving it for awhile. It takes quite a bit of pressure to load them with the sub bases, certainly a lot more than just the sabot alone, so maybe that is enough to prevent misfires. I wonder if making a habit of tamping the load down with the ram rod every day would alleviate that problem?
If I were just hunting in Indiana I stick with the Barnes bullets of the XTPs but since I am going to be hunting open country for pressured public land deer I want the additional range. More importantly, since I may not have time to range the deer, I want a load that has a point blank range as far as possible.
Thanks for the help guys, especially the first handle terminal performance reports timex!
|
|
|
Post by mbogo on Sept 19, 2011 19:21:53 GMT -5
Timex, were you using the .357s or the .40s?
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Sept 19, 2011 20:40:20 GMT -5
.357/195 Duplex -- they shot the best, bought a few of the others, but these seemed to work the best,
|
|
|
Post by hornharvester on Sept 19, 2011 22:50:23 GMT -5
Another reason Ive never been keen on PR bullets is back when the Savage 10ML first came out I called the owner Cecil Epps and asked him which of his bullets would work best for smokeless muzzle loading. He proceeded to chew my butt out about smokeless muzzle loading and told me it had no place in the muzzle loading world. He actually got quite nasty about it. I thanked him for his time and hung up.
A few years later Cecil starts promoting his smokeless muzzle loading stuff on his website. A complete 180 degree turn around. That being said I think his bullets work better using Black powder subs.
For long distance shooting there are better bullets that have very good B.C.. Heavier bullets shoot flatter than lighter bullets at distance plus they carry more energy.
Ive found one of the cheapest things you can do to a Savage to improve accuracy is to bed the action. If you do the work yourself materials cost less than 20.00. Also check the front scope base to see that it doesnt sit up on the recoil lug. Some do as the factory lug sticks up a bit and this causes the base not to be seated square on the action. Also the front scope base mounting screw can bottom out before its tight. Simple fix is to grind a thread or two off the screw. And lastly service your breech plug every 30 shots or so by drilling out the carbon. The carbon closes up the holes and makes accuracy go away. Vent liners should be changed when they get .036 - .038 thousands in size. h.h.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Sept 20, 2011 6:40:59 GMT -5
What could cause a heavier bullet to have a flatter trajectory than a high BC lighter bullet, unless it's bone crushing powder charges.
In you opinion, what are the best bullets to use for 200+ yard shots in the 50 and for the 45?
|
|